Whitman
Forensics Newsletter
Vol.
10, No. 2, June, 2004 |
||
|
NPTE—Climbing the Mountain! Throughout
the year, nearly every team in the nation is frantically checking the NPTE
website to see where they rank from week to week…and with good reason, only
the top 48 teams in the nation are extended an invitation to attend this
prestigious tournament. This year
Whitman had the honor of sending 2 teams to the The tournament got off to an early
start…even earlier for the Whitman
debaters since head coach Jim |
Beth P, Chris, Scott, Pluto, Brian D, Jim, and Rob at |
|
|
Hanson
serves as the president of the NPTE and had to make sure that the tab room
and food were setup. Throughout the
first day, teams counted ballots hoping to get the 7 needed to advance to outrounds. The team of Whitman GT were relieved to
have picked up their 7th ballot during the 5th round
and picked up an additional ballot during round 6 giving them a ballot record
of 8-4. Unfortunately, Rob and |
||
|
The first out round featured
Whitman GT vs. Claremont BD. Whitman
handed The third elimination round pitted
Whitman GT against UPS AC who were looking for blood
as Whitman had eliminated their other team in the previous round. The decision came out 3-0 in favor of
Whitman. By this point there was an
almost unexplainable excitement as Gorman and Thompson seemed to be clicking
as a team like they never had before.
With three victories and only one ballot dropped Whitman GT was at the
top of the bracket and received byes into the semi-finals round. The semis pitted Whitman GT on the opposition against year long Northwest rivals Lewis and Clark BW on the topic, “Resolved: Saddam Hussein should be tried by an international tribunal.” Whitman GT showed |
Jim, Jackie, Chris C, Chandra, Chris G, |
|
|
Lewis
and Clark the exit sign as they won on a 3-0 decision. This set up the final round of |
||
|
|
In
case you didn’t already know, |
|
|
IE Spectacular This
year was a great year for the Whitman Individual Events program, with lots of
fresh new ideas and competitors bringing home trophies. Coached by Brian Danielson and Katie Imbeau, the team has much to cheer about. Frosh Stephen Reed made a dramatic entrance
(excuse the pun) into interpretive events.
Steve nearly qualified for the NIET in Dramatic Interpretation and
Programmed Oral Interpretation with a first place finish at the |
||
|
|
||
|
Joe, Samantha, Jim, and Brian
pose. Staff: Jim Hanson, Director of Forensics, Joe Carver, Assistant Policy Coach;
Brian Danielson, Assistant Parliamentary and I.E. Coach; Samantha Howell,
Student Assistant and Intramural Debate Manager; Brian Simmonds
and Thad Blank, National Circuit assistant policy coaches; Katie Imbeau, Dramatic Interpretation Student Assistant; Bob Withycombe, Chair, Rhetoric and Film Studies; and Thomas
Cronin, President, Whitman College. 43 Competitors,
2003-2004:
The
Parli team eating it up at NPDA Nationals End of
the Year Party As usual, the end of the year is an
extremely busy time on the Whitman campus.
Despite being busy writing up cases and working on individual events
for next year, the team let their hair down and partied it up with a Cinco de Mayo celebration at Jim’s house. Many individuals arrived early to help Jim
set up for the party (and to get first dibs on the food). The team spent the early part of the party
watching the World Series of Poker and wondering if former policy coach Brian
Simmonds will ever make it to the final round and
win some serious money. The team’s own Matt Schissler served as head chef showing off his epicurean
skills with a masterfully done salmon.
Assistant Coach Brian Danielson broke in Jim’s new BBQ with a flank
steak. Jim even got into the mix
making his famous (at least to the debate team) guacamole dip. There were appetizers galore and the dinner
was finished off with a choice of pies, cheesecake, and ice cream. After stuffing themselves full of
delicious food, the team gathered around to share in the warm glow of some
good natured embarrassment with the traditional “Awards Ceremony.” Jim Hanson showed off his oratory skills by
serving as MC of the event, managing not to be booed out of his own
house. The team also shared stories
from throughout the year of memorable rounds and moments chatting late into the
night. Suffice it to say a good time
was had by all.
Samantha’s beloved KISS T-Shirt Andrew Lum shows
his dramatic skills!
Bob smiles for the camera! |
Graduating
Seniors Each year when the
warm sun of May is inviting many Whitman students out to Chris Gorman is
graduating with a BA in Politics, writing his thesis on the political
ramifications of rap music, focusing on the artists Dead Prez. The entire team can attest to his
commitment to making sure that he was doing extensive “research” on the music
because he made sure that the whole team listened along with him while
traveling at debate tournaments. His
current plans involve working for a Public Interest Research Group. Former team member Brant Olson (Class of
2001) also began life in the “real world” with the PIRGs. Sam Spiegel will
also be graduating with a BA in Politics.
Sam has shown strong debate and interpretation skills. Sam also spent
many hours whiling away at his thesis and playing on the tennis team. His laughter and tight abs will be missed
by the team and by random folks in the Senior Emily Marr, is also graduating with a BA in Politics. She
excelled in policy debate, advancing to elimination rounds at CEDA Nationals
in both her frosh and sophomore year. Her persistent questioning such as “Am
I getting an A?” and “Why is this professor so pathetic?” will be remembered.
J Samantha Howell,
Jim’s assistant, graduates. Samantha has been making sure that hotel and car
reservations have been made, filing away ballots from tournaments, and
running the IM debate tournaments for the past two years. Most importantly, she has made sure that
Jim doesn’t melt down at the High School tournament. While Samantha is departing Whitman, she is
leaving behind her “You Suck and That’s Sad” bunny poster to remind Jim of
her every time he looks up from his desk. Sophomore Andrew Lum will be replacing
Samantha. Assistant Coach
Brian Danielson will also be leaving the team to pursue a Masters degree in
Communications at the Taking his place
will be former Whitman policy debater, Dave Guidry (Class of 2003). Dave has been living in The team will also
be joined by a strong group of incoming first year students who we’ll
introduce to you in the fall edition of our newsletter. Joe Carver, returns as policy assistant as does Katie Imbeau, student interpretation assistant, and Thad Blank
and Brian Simmonds will help out at tournaments
with the policy team. IM
Debates, Dramatic Interp, and Dovell-Gose Contest The IM Championship
topic put the focus on the Whitman community itself with the topic: The next
Mike Winnike, IM winner! Matt and Martin in the IM semis! The Dovell
Gose Oratory Contest has been held annually since
the 1920s. This year there were many
excellent speeches but taking first place was Beth Pearson whose speech focused
on the FDA’s recommendation to grant over-the-counter status to emergency
contraception. Eric Suni took second place with a speech on recent changes in
the Whitman P-D-F grading policy.
Third place went to Patrick Carter, whose speech engaged in an
analysis of Christian Radio broadcasts. Policy
Debate: The NDT Whitman
qualified for the NDT for the 8th year in a row. Held at The
Catholic University of America in |
|
|
|
||
|
Cathryn Posey and Scott Thompson join Cornell West who
visited campus.
The Parli-IE Squad for
2003-2004.
The
Policy Squad for 2003-2004. A Bull
Ride! At
NPDA Nats, the team went to Universal Studio’s City
Walk for a bit of sight seeing and lunch before the awards ceremony. After eating the team paused for pictures
in front of the Universal Studio’s globe and noticed that there was a
mechanical bull. Although Jim could
not be persuaded to get on, Assistant Coach Brian Danielson, Chris Gorman,
Chris Chamness, Scott Thompson, and Stephen Reed
decided to have an impromptu “King of the Bull” contest. Brian Danielson, despite having previous
experience on a mechanical bull finished dead last, Chris Chamness
took third, Scott “Scooter” Thompson, hung on to take second. However, the title of “King of the Bull”
was rightfully claimed by Chris “I never should have got on this thing.” Gorman, held on for over 30 seconds, but at
the end, was woefully unprepared for the fall, injuring his shoulder
requiring a trip to the emergency room. At the hospital, a drunken woman
waiting for her husband provided some comic relief as she proceeded to reveal
all sorts of personal information to the security guard leaving the waiting
room in stitches. Chris’ shoulder has since recovered.
Kathryn Nav
Jeff Ben
Ross Eric |
Riding
the Beast—NPDA Nationals 2004! Debating at the NPDA National
Tournament is always a challenge.
With a vast pool of unknown critics and teams, the tournament is often
likened to riding a bull, where you try to hold on for as many rounds as
possible. This year was no
exception. The 2004 NPDA National
Tournament, hosted by California State University Northridge, was the largest
collegiate debate tournament in history with over 310 teams competing and a
nearly full quad octafinals break. The team traveled from
Parli debaters The
next day, after arriving in
Chris’s
ill fated bull ride;; Policy
Debate Second Semester Policy Debate
at
Policy
team eating it up at Meghan’s! A month later, the whole Northwest
loaded into what was called the “love bus” and drove to the beautiful bay
area for the Berkeley Tournament. Eric Suni and
Beth Schueler were able to advance to the out
rounds before losing to NDT Double Octo-finalists, |
|
|
A
smooth talker that Suni is. Next up, we were headed
to No time to be down though. Jim
Hanson, our fearless leader, always looking for another educational
experience (points!), scooted the policy debaters into Parliamentary Debate
at the You don’t have to be at Whitman
long to know how important the Northwest CEDA Champs is to this squad.
Despite it being a small tournament, it is fierce and it brings the
competitive fire out in each of the kids. This year we came packed with four
teams and hoped to take the crown. Preliminary rounds went exceptionally well
with Whitman occupying the 1st, 2nd and 3rd seedings
at the end of the preliminary rounds. In out-rounds the following morning,
Jeff and Ben wound up 5th, and Eric and Beth and Ross and Matt
were 3rd. Without a single senior – we feel pretty confident about
bringing it back home at the earliest opportunity. CEDA Nationals saw both Eric and
Beth and Ben and Jeff win five rounds and qualify to debate in out-rounds.
Matt and Ross missed out-rounds as an all-frosh team by one debate. What
happened next is sure to feed arguments about whether brackets should be
broken or not--Eric and Beth were paired against Jeff and Ben in triples.
Unfortunately for the young and spirited critical team from Whitman, Ben Meiches had not cut his hair in over a year and so
Whitman SS advanced to debate Cal State Fullerton CW in the double octo-finals. The CSUF team was on a mission and Whitman’s
CEDA Nationals ended but not before Eric and Beth were awarded Academic All
American and All American Honors. BRAVO. |
||
|
|
||
|
Withycombe
and Walker Fund Contributions We are grateful for your
contributions to the forensic team! Generous donors December 1, 2003 through
June 20, 2004 include: Boeing Corporation, David A. Kearney, Derek M. Banducci, Ellen Y. and Erland
A. Suni, James B. Hanson, Janice Gordon, Janice
Sandra Berman, Jared Phillips and Loan Lam, Jason P. Smith, Jennifer Becker
& Andrew Backlund, John R. Miller, Microsoft
Corporation, Nicole A. and Matthew P. Levin, Peter B. Stiffler,
Rachelle N. and David B. Perry-Campf, Robert and
Beverly Hanson, Robert M. Withycombe, Stephen C.
Rowe. If we
missed you, please tell us because we do appreciate your support! Send contributions to the Walker Fund or the Withycombe Fund
to: Annual
Fund Office; Checks should be made out to The Team’s History Page: www.whitman.edu/rhetoric/history/ |
Members of the team circa 1905! |
||
|
Beth hugs Charles
who joined us for the holiday party.
Eric dances on Ben; Matt & Meghan laugh. |
|||
|
POLICY AWARDS “Top 25 in the NDT and CEDA Rankings
as a squad despite our youth and several tournament cancellations in the
Northwest. Watch out for this coming year .” ALEX BOLLINGER AND
DANIELLE WILLIAMSON LEWIS-CLARK,
FIRST, JR 1-5
(Junior 1st place; Alex 1st speaker; Danielle 2nd speaker) ALEX BOLLINGER AND
KIRSTEN DUSENBERRY
(Gonzaga) UC-BERKELEY,
2ND, JR 5-1,
3-0 semis, 1-2 finals, Alex speaker award BEN MEICHES AND JEFF
BUNTIN USC,
4-3,
1-2 doubles NW
CEDA CHAMP, FIFTH 6-0,
0-3 quarters, Ben 3rd speaker; Jeff 6th speaker CEDA
NATS, 33RD 5-3,
closeout in triples BETH SCHUELER AND ERIC
SUNI GONZAGA,
THIRD 4-3,
3-0 octas, 2-1 quarters, 0-3 semis; Beth 7th
speaker LEWIS-CLARK,
SECOND 5-1,
2-1 semis, 0-3 finals; Beth 2nd speaker; Eric 1st speaker USC,
17TH 5-2,
0-3 doubles 5-1,
0-3 octas; Eric 6th speaker, Beth speaker award NORTHWESTERN,
17TH 6-2,
0-3 doubles NW
CEDA CHAMPS, 3RD 5-1,
2-1 quarters, 1-2 semis; Beth 2nd speaker; Eric 4th speaker CEDA
NATIONALS, 17TH 5-3,
closeout in triples, 0-3 in doubles; Beth 26th speaker NDT,
29TH 4-4
(15 ballots) DANA RANDALL AND MIKE
WINNIKE USC,
FIRST 7-0,
3-0, closeout, Dana 3rd speaker; Mike 4th speaker JEFF BUNTIN AND ROSS
RICHENDRFER GONZAGA,
FIFTH 4-3,
2-1 octas, 0-3 quarters LEWIS-CLARK,
FIFTH 4-2;
Jeff 8th speaker MATT SCHISSLER AND
ROSS RICHENDRFER USC,
FIRST JR 7-0,
3-0 semis, closeout finals; Matt 1st speaker; Ross 2nd speaker NW
CEDA CHAMPS, 3RD 5-1,
2-1 quarters, 0-3 semis MEGHAN HUGHES AND NAV
REKHI USC,
FIRST JR 7-0,
3-0, closeout, Nav 5th speaker 5-2,
3-0 quarters, 3-0 semis, 1-2 finals |
INDIVIDUAL EVENTS “Lots of talent among our students
doing individual events.” ALEX BOLLINGER DRAMATIC SECOND,
NOVICE, WWU BETH PEARSON IMPROMPTU FIRST
Jr, BRIDGET KUSTIN INFORMATIVE FINALIST,
Lewis and Clark CHANDRA IMPROMPTU SECOND,
CHRIS CHAMNESS AFTER
DINNER SPEAKING FINALIST,
Lewis and Clark IMPROMPTU SECOND,
JR, WWU CHRIS GORMAN IMPROMPTU THIRD,
Lewis and Clark; FINALIST, EXTEMP THIRD,
HOLLY BLACK DRAMATIC Finalist,
Novice, Pacific JACKIE JENKINS INFORMATIVE THIRD,
WWU KATHRYN BERGH IMPROMPTU FINALIST,
Pacific (Novice), FIRST, WWU EXTEMP FINALIST,
Novice Lewis and Clark SECOND,
Novice, WWU FINALIST, Novice, SIXTH,
KIM SCHLESINGER EXTEMP SECOND,
JR, Lewis and Clark; SECOND, Jr, KYLE GOTCHY DRAMATIC THIRD,
Lewis and Clark LAURA HANSON EXTEMP FIRST,
Novice, Lewis and Clark, FIRST, Novice, WWU IMPROMPTU THIRD,
Novice, WWU LAZARO CARRION DRAMATIC FIRST,
Jr, PATRICK CARTER COMM.
ANALYSIS FINALIST,
Lewis and Clark; FINALIST, Pacific; FINALIST, WWU IMPROMPTU FINALIST,
JR Lewis and Clark; FINALIST, Novice, WWU POI FINALIST,
WWU; FINALIST Jr, ROB OLSEN EXTEMP FIFTH,
ROSS RICHENDRFER IMPROMPTU FIRST,
Novice, Lewis and Clark SAM SPEIGEL PROSE SECOND,
WWU; FINALIST, STEPHEN REED AND
TRAVIS PETERSEN DUO
INTERP FINALIST,
STEPHEN REED DRAMATIC FINALIST,
Lewis and Clark; FIRST, Pacific POI;
FINALIST, Pacific; FIRST, WWU TERI SWARTS AND TYLER
KENT DUO
INTERP FINALIST,
Lewis and Clark |
PARLI DEBATE “Second in the nation as a squad
and second place at the NPTE! And, almost all return!” ALEX BOLLINGER AND
JACKIE JENKINS WWU,
FIRST Jr, 6-0, octas thru quarters wins; Alex, 1st speaker, Jackie 6th
speaker 4-2,
octas loss NPDA
NATIONALS, 65TH 6-2,
quads loss BEN MEICHES AND JEFF
BUNTIN 3-3,
Ben 4th speaker; Jeff, 14th speaker BETH PEARSON AND KIM
SCHLESINGER 5-1,
octas loss NPDA
NATIONALS, 65TH 5-3,
quads loss BETH SCHUELER AND ERIC
SUNI 3-3,
octas thru finals, wins, Beth 16th speaker BRIDGET KUSTIN AND
CHRIS GORMAN REED,
FIRST 5-1;
Octas-Finals, wins LEWIS
AND CLARK Clark, FIRST 5-1;
Octas-Finals, wins PACIFIC,
FIRST 4-2,
Octas-Finals, wins CHANDRA REED,
THIRD 3-3;
Octas-Quarters, wins; Semis loss; Chandra, 8th
speaker LEWIS
AND CLARK, NINTH 5-1,
Octas loss. UC-SAN
DIEGO, NINTH 6-2,
octas loss Point
Loma, 4-2 CHRIS CHAMNESS AND
STEPHEN REED LEWIS
AND CLARK, THIRD, JR 4-2,
Octas-Quarters wins; Semis loss PACIFIC,
SECOND 5-1,
Octas-Semis, wins; Finals, loss, Stephen 7th
speaker (Junior) CHRIS GORMAN AND
CHANDRA 5-1;
Octas-Finals, wins; Chris, 9th speaker CHRIS GORMAN AND SCOTT
THOMPSON 6-0,
octas win, quarters loss UC-SAN
DIEGO, FIRST 6-0,
octas-finals wins; Chris second speaker WWU,
NINTH 3-3,
octas loss; Chris 3rd speaker; Scott 13th speaker POINT
LOMA, NINTH 6-0,
doubles win, octas loss, Chris 17th speaker 6-0,
octas win, quarters loss; Chris 15th speaker NPTE,
SECOND! 8-4
ballots, 6-0 in first 6 elims; loss in finals on a
79-23 ballot NPDA
NATIONALS, NINTH 7-1,
quads, triples, doubles wins; octas loss EMILY MARR AND SAM
SPIEGEL REED,
NINTH 4-2;
Octas loss ERIC SUNI AND SAM
SPEIGEL WWU,
NINTH 4-2,
octas loss HUGO VARGAS AND
PATRICK CARTER LEWIS
AND CLARK, FIFTH, JR 4-2;
Octas, win; Quarters, loss, Patrick 5th speaker PACIFIC,
NINTH, JR 4-2;
Octas loss. WWU,
FIFTH, JR 6-0,
octas win, quarters loss, Patrick 2nd speaker PLU,
SECOND, JR 4-2,
semis win, finals loss, Patrick 1st speaker JAMES HOVARD AND LAURA
HANSON LEWIS-CLARK,
SECOND, NOVICE 4-2,
Octas-Semis, wins; Finals, loss; Laura 4th speaker SPOKANE
FALLS, FIFTH, NOVICE 4-2;
Laura 1st speaker; James 7th speaker KIM SCHLESINGER AND
ROB OLSEN LEWIS
AND CLARK, FIRST, JR 4-2,
Octas-Finals, wins REED,
NINTH 5-1,
Octas loss 4-2,
octas loss WWU,
THIRD 4-2,
octas-quarters wins, semis, loss MATT SCHISSLER AND
ROSS RICHENDRFER 4-2;
Octas loss, Ross, 6th speaker |
|
|
Chris C. gives the
bull a try! |
Bob does what he’s best at—taking
people’s money while gambling! |
| |