1927-1928 Whitman Speech and Debate Team

William
Earl Beem

Edith
Davis and Prof. Blankenship who also taught in the English department
The
Wrangler’s club for freshmen is established in 1927.

Whitman News
I.
A.
New
Staff
1)
Col.
Robert Allen Burton – Counselor of
2)
Professor
H. Wyatt – Professor of Education
B.
Mark
Bradford was ASWC President
C.
Alice
McPherson was ASWC Vice President
D.
Arthur
Jones was ASWC Secretary
E.
Dr. Stephen B. L. Penrose was the College President (as well as being head of
the education and philosophy departments)
F.
William Earl Beem was the debate coach/DOF
G.
Catherine
Bleakney was women’s debate manager
H.
Chester
Babcock was the men’s debate manager
II.
At
A.
Enrollment
was 535
B.
The
Faculty voted to return to the semester system after the S.A.T.C. (a World War
I measure) had forced them into a trimester system. The students opposed this
move.
C.
Graduation
requirements were changed:
The reading knowledge requirement in foreign language was abolished
The physical education requirement was reduced from 2 years to 1 year
D.
There
was a mumps outbreak. Various halls were quarantined at one point or another.
E.
The
physics department decided to add a radio course for the 1928-29 year.
F.
80%
of men at Whitman worked through school
G.
50%
of women at Whitman had part time jobs
H.
The
Blue Moon (Whitman’s literary magazine) after being cancelled due to financial
problems, was revived by Professor Blankenship, and students Lyman Lynn, Paul
Smithson, and Bud Lynch
I.
5
members of the faculty were included in “Who’s Who in
President Penrose
Louis F. Anderson (professor of Greek and Vice President of the college – he
was also the father of the 1st President of Whitman)
Professor Walter Andrew Bratton (head of mathematics department)
Professor Howard Stidham Brode
(Professor of Biology)
Professor Edward E. Ruby (head of the Latin Department)
J.
Flappers
were an established social group
K.
Whitman
won the Northwest Conference in Basketball for the 3rd straight year
L.
Baseball
won the Northwest Conference
M.
Track
won their conference meet
N.
The
gym was undergoing renovation
O.
Pio ads centered mostly around banks,
confectionaries, and clothing
Speech in the English Department News
(1928)
COURSES
IN SPEAKING
6. Public Speaking.—This course aims to
develop the ability to speak effectively. It includes instruction in the
principles of oral composition, correction of voice and speech defects,
training in right vocal habits, and practice in speaking. Sections are limited
to fifteen students. Required of Freshmen. One hour, first and second
semesters.
7. Argumentation and Debate.—The aim of this
course is not so much to develop skill in formal debate as to give the student
the power to consider disputed questions calmly and logically. Students
interested in intercollegiate forensics are advised to take this course. Open
to Sophomores, Juniors, and Seniors. Three hours, first semester.
8. Forms of Public Address.—The course includes a
study of selected addresses prepared for special occasions and practice in the
composition and delivery of occasional speeches. Open to Juniors
and Seniors. Two hours, second semester.
30. Extemporaneous Speaking.—Practice in extemporaneous
speaking on topics of current interest. Open to Sophomores,
Juniors, and Seniors. Two hours, first
semester.
9. Dramatic
Interpretation and Play Production.—In the first semester, this course gives instruction and training in
dramatic interpretation; in the second semester, in play production. Open to Juniors and Seniors, and to Sophomores by consent of the instructor.
The enrollment is limited to twenty students. Three hours, first semester; two hours, second semester.
THE JOHN BRINING PRIZES IN FRESHMAN
EXTEMPORANEOUS SPEAKING.—Mr. John Brining, of
THE WILLIAM THOMAS DOVELL PRIZES IN ORATORY.— Alumni
members of the Board of Overseers have established two prizes, one of thirty
dollars and one of twenty dollars, in memory of the late William Thomas Dovell, a member of the Class of 1888, upon the following
conditions:
The
prizes are awarded upon the basis of an oratorical contest to be held during
Commencement week, provided that at least four contestants participate. The
contest is open to members of the Sophomore, Junior,
and Senior classes. The orations are limited to two thousand words. Contestants
present their subjects to the head of the English Department for approval not
later than the third Tuesday of February. If more than six contestants submit
orations, they present them to the head of the English Department not later
than April 15 for submission to a board of judges on thought and composition
who select the six best orations for the Commencement contest. The judges on
thought and on delivery are selected by a committee consisting of the President
of the College and the heads of the departments of English and History. (1918)
DELTA SIGMA RHO, national honorary
forensic fraternity, has established a chapter at the College. Membership is
earned in part by participation in at least two intercollegiate contests.
THE ASSOCIATED STUDENTS OF WHITMAN
COLLEGE, an organization of which every student is a member, has control of
student activities in athletics, in journalism, in debate and oratory, and in
music. The dues, $7.50 per semester, payable by every student, are collected by
the Bursar of the College.
The Joins Brining Prizes in Freshman
Extemporaneous Speaking—
First:
Second: LOYAL ILIF PERRY, Class of 1980
The William Thomas Dovell Prizes in Oratory— Tied for
CLARK


World News
III.
In
the world
A.
B.
C.
Belgian
George Lemaitre postulated the Big Bang theory
D.
Sacco
and Vanzetti were executed on August 23, 1927
E.
Philo
T. Farnsworth unveils television in
F.
CBS
started its first radio broadcasts on September 18, 1927
G.
The Jazz Singer, widely accepted as
the first “talkie” movie, was released on October 6, 1927
H.
The
US Supreme Court upheld the lower court rulings in the
I.
Ford
unveiled its Model A on December 2, 1927
J.
The
Senate refused to seat Senators elect Frank Smith (
K.
Showboat debuted on Broadway
on December 27, 1927
L.
Stalin
purges the communist party and consolidates his control of the
M.
(1928)
In the wake of the 1927 Mississippi River flooding, the U.S. government adopts
the Flood Control Act, a $325 million, 10-year program to control floods with
dams built by army engineers.
N.
Amelia
Earhart made the first transatlantic flight by a woman between June 17 and 18,
1928
O.
P.
The
Q.
“On March 1st, the US Army Air Corps received the first of its order of 13 B-17
bombers.”
R.
The “Neutrality Act, which became known as the "Third Neutrality
Act," extended the US Neutrality Acts to civil wars.”
S. “After traveling from
T.
“On July 7th, Japanese troops clashed in maneuvers with Chinese troops at the
U.
“
V.
The “Royal Commission calls for partition of
W. “Amelia Earhart
was lost over the Pacific in her attempt to make an around-the-world flight
along the equator.”
X.
“Somoza family gains control over
Y
“On November 11, 1937,
Z.
“On December 12th, Japanese planes bombed a


IV.
Debate at Whitman
A. The
Men’s team included Richard Van Horn, Eugene Klise,
Henry Taylor, Clark Eckart, Chester Babcock, Carlise Roberts, and Loyal Perry
B. The Men
debated the topic “Resolved, That investors and investments in Foreign
countries should be protected only by the government of the Nation in which the
investment is made.”
C. The Men
debated six rounds and they won three, lost two, and had one No decision.
D. The
Women’s team included members Dorothy Jack, Hilda Gaylord, Sophie Kirshen, Marjory Nelson, Agnes Clarke, Harriet Ahearn,
Catherine Bleakney, and Elizabeth Galloway
E. The
Women debated two topics.
1. “Resolved, That
co-education in American colleges and universities is a failure.”
2. “Resolved, That the policy of mass education in the American
institutions of higher learning be condemned.”
F. The
Women’s team debated in two contests losing both.
G. Whitman was part of the Pacific
Coast Forensic League which included eleven Members from
H.
Harry Rothrock represented Whitman at the national
speech tournament in
V.
IM Debate at Whitman
A. Trophies were offered for the
first time this year. This was done to encourage Competition. The IM contests
became a matter of class pride.
B. The Men
debated the topic “Resolved, That insanity as a plea for a crime Be abolished.”
C. Freshmen Kenneth Davis and Ralph
Edgerton defeated Juniors Harold Fleharty and Charles
Ogden to win the IM debates.
D. The
Women debated the topic “Resolved, That advertising plays too great a Part in
the life of the American people.”
E. Freshmen Ruth Blaine and Lola
Sims defeated Sophomores Irmal Kinnison
And Verna Rasmusser and
Juniors Leila Lundy and Eleanor Dunlop To win the IM debates.
VI.
Whitman IM Speech Contests
A. The Dovell Oratory contest was split between Chester Babcock
and Harry Rothrock who each tied for first.
B. Freshmen were not allowed to
compete in the Dovell Contest. They had a Contest of
their own called the John Brining Extemporaneous Speech Contest.
1. It gave a long list
of topics with three hours of preparation to the contestants. Twelve finalists
were announced.
2. Carlisle Roberts and
Loyal Perry won the awards in the Women’s and Men’s divisions respectively.

The past year has been one of interest to
followers of the Whitman debating teams. Although debate does not draw the
crowds that other outside activities of the college do, the people of the
Northwest have probably heard more about the Missionary's forensic activities
this year than they have of any of his other undertakings.
A new coach took over the reigns last
fall, and one of the biggest events of the year faced him shortly after school
opened. W. Earl Beem of
During the year two other men's debates
were held, one of which was a dual debate, and six men were broken into the
game. All but one of these will return to school next year. Two representatives
were also entered in the Pacific Forensic League contest, and both placed. One
of these will be lost by graduation.
In the women's section only one veteran
came out for debate, and a triangular contest and a dual debate shortly faced
the squad. Quick work on the part of Coach Beem again
came to the rescue, and four new candidates were ready to take the field when
the time came. Three of these women varsity debaters will be lost by
graduation, but the two remaining will have as their colleagues next year an
experienced group of women who were out for interclass debate.
The success of the season is due largely
to the efforts of the coach. Handicaps seemed but opportunities to him, and he
has already started preparations for a next year's schedule that promises to be
nearly twice as big as the one just completed.
WHITMAN MEETS
Early in the fall the men's rebate squad
was called out to begin preparations for the second inter-continental debate in
the history of the school. Hardly a month was at hand in which to break in an
entirely new squad, but hard work on the part of the men turning out gave Coach
Beem confidence enough to pick a trio and begin
training them to meet the experienced
The question chosen was: "Resolved, that the modern press exercises a harmful
influence on the community," and the Whitman team, composed of Harry Rothrock, Mark Bradford, and Chester Babcock, upheld the
negative side of the resolution.
Sydney H. Heathwood,
Noel D. Mackintosh, and John R. Godsall spoke for the
Australian university. All three of these men had had considerable experience,
and two of them had debated two years previous against the
The debate was featured by the cleverness
and wit of the members of both teams, and at times the audience was kept in an
uproar by the brilliant comparisons used. It was a no-decision debate, and
newspapers of the city did not express an opinion because of the closeness of
the contest.
INTERCLASS DEBATE
This year for the first time in the
history of the school the men's and women's interclass debaters completed a
forensic schedule and were award-ed bronze plaques
for their winning work. The men argued on the question: "Resolved, that
all students be prohibited from operating cars while attending college"
and the women discussed the co-educational problem in the
After a series of elimination contests in
which debaters were graded individually the following class champions were
picked: Men, Seniors: Harry Johnson and Philip von Lubken; Juniors: Glenn Davidson and Henry Taylor;
Sophomores: Charles Ogden and Glenn Brogger;
Freshmen: Wilmar Froistad
and Loyal Perry. In the women's division no Junior
team was entered. The other class teams were: Seniors, Lenore Martin and Mary
Walker; Sophomores' Betty O'Brien and Sophie Kirshen; and Freshmen Helen Graham and Clare Applegate.
In the finals, which were held during
chapel hours in the early part of March' the Junior
men emerged victorious over their Freshmen rivals, and the Senior women
defeated the Sophomore champions for the coveted trophy.
The two plaques
upon which the names of the winning teams were engraved, were presented to the
school by the Rev. Hugh Elmer Brown of Evanston, Illinois and were awarded for
the first time this year. It is thought that even a greater interest will be
shown in interclass debate next year than was shown during its first year of
organization, and Coach Beem expects to uncover many
promising varsity debaters by means of these debates.
EXTEMPORANEOUS SPEAKING CONTEST
For the first time in the history of the
school a Whitman student place in the Pacific Coast Extemporaneous Speaking
contest, which was this year held at Corvallis Harry Rothrock,
a Sophomore, represented the college in this meet, and carried off first honors
with a Southern California student placing second and the Washington State
College representative getting third place. Rothrock,
after an hour's preparation, spoke on "The History of the United States'
Policy in Respect to the West Indian Republics of Central America
ORATORICAL CONTEST
On April 8, the night following the
Extemporaneous Speaking contest Preston Butler spoke in
OTHER CONTESTS
Speaking contests of every description are
continually being held in
The Dovell
Contest
The William Thomas Dovell
prizes in oratory were given last commencement to Gordon Hannaford and Jack Gose, both of whom have graduated. The prizes given each
year are thirty dollars and twenty, and this year four speakers have already
been chosen to contest for the money in June. They are:
The John Brining Contest
Last year's Freshman Extemporaneous
Speaking contest was won by Betty O'Brien, with Eugene Klise
placing second. Prizes of twenty and ten dollars are given each year to the
winners of this contest, who draw subjects and are given three hours in which
to prepare them. A great wealth of material is at hand this year from which to
pick speakers for the finals and this event promises to be one of the most
hotly contested in many years
Frosh Oratorical Contest
Last year an oratorical contest was held
for the Freshmen, and a considerable amount of talent
was discovered among these youngsters. The four finalists spoke during the
chapel hour, and Chester Babcock was awarded first place,
and Virginia Humphrey second. The others reaching the finals over a large field
of entries were Eugene Klise and Hilda Gaylord
On December 7, 1927, the Whitman debate team faced off
against a trio of debaters from
H.L. Elvin, M.A.B. King-Hamilton and
H.M. Foot spoke for
WOMEN'S
TRIANGULAR
On
February 16 Lenore Martin and Dorothy Jack met the negative team from
Washington State College in the college chapel on the question: "Resolved,
that the United States adopt a uniform marriage and divorce law." On the
same evening the Whitman negative team, composed of Maurine Hall and Mary
Walker journeyed to Moscow and debated the Univer- sity of Idaho debaters on the same question. At the same
time a team from the University was in
COLLEGE
OF IDAHO DUAL DEBATE
"Resolved: that a
national board of censorship be established by congress to control exhibitions
and the release of all moving pictures" was the question discussed by the teams
representing the College of Idaho and Whitman on Saturday evening, April
16. Catherine Bleakney and Dorothy Jack,
upholding the negative side of the question, won a 2 to 1 decision over the
Idaho women on the Whitman floor, while Mary Walker and Lenore Martin,,
who traveled to Caldwell to argue the affirmative side of the resolution, lost
by a split vote. The home debate was
unique in that it was broadcast by remote control from MacDowell Hall through
station KOWW, Walla Walla. This was the first debate to be sent out over the
wires from Whitman College, and the first women's debate to be broadcast in
this section of the country.
O. A. C. DEBATE
On
Wednesday evening, March 9, Clark Eckart and
Harry Rothrock met the Oregon Agricultural College
affirmative team in the college chapel on the question: "Resolved, that foreign nations immediately relinquish all
governmental control in China, excepting that usually exercised by consulates
and legations." It was the first time in several years that the two
schools had met, and dopesters had it rightly figured
that this would be one of the best debates of the year. Both sides got a good
deal of applause on their smashing rebuttals, as these were the features of the
debate. The visiting team went home with a well earned 2 to I decision.
The
Chinese question was again under fire in two debates between the College of
Puget Sound and Whitman which were held April 18 and April 28. Chester Babcock and
Kenneth Garner took the trip to Tacoma for the first of the debates' and upheld
the negative side of the question in Jones Hall before one of the largest
crowds that has ever witnessed a forensic con- test in the sound city. The Tacomans kept an unanimous
decision in their own home town, but according to reports Whitman's team made a
very creditable showing, despite the adverse decision of the judges. Ten days
later Howard Manning and Clark Eckart were hosts to
the C. P. S. negative team in
IV.
Debate
at Whitman
A.
Whitman
had the only chapter of Delta Sigma Rho (a debate honor society) in the state
1) Members:
Faculty: William R. Davis and George B. Marquis
Students: Clark Eckart,
Catherine Bleakney, Mark Bradford, Harry Rothrock, Chester Babcock, Dorothy Jack, Alfred McVay
2) Hilda Gaylord, Sophia Kirshen, Elizabeth Galloway,
Kenneth Garner, Eugene Klise, and Henry Taylor were
inducted in spring 1928
B.
Farm
organizations:
1) Freshmen Ralph Edgerton, Philip Davis, and Fred Sundquist
of the Wranglers’ Club (an on campus farm organization for Whitman debate)
debated Walla Walla High School on the resolution “Resolved, that the President
and Vice President of the US should be elected for a single, 6-year term
constitutionally waived.”
Later in the year they debated Mac-Hi on the resolution “Resolved, that the
jury system should be so changed as to permit a verdict by less than unanimous
vote” (12 mi.n constructives;
one 5min rebuttal per team)
2) Ye Talke
Shoppe (the women’s equivalent of the Wranglers’ Club) was formed. It
consisted of 20 women. Dorothy Jack was the President, Elizabeth Galloway was
the Vice President, and Elma Proffitt was the
Secretary/Treasurer.
3) On December 1 they met to debate the resolution “Resolved: that this house
disapproves of woman.” The women of Ye Talke Shoppe
were Aff.
C.
The
women’s debate team consisted of 8 members: Dorothy Jack, Hilda Gaylord, Sophie
Kirshen, Catherine Bleakney,
Katherin Kiesling,
Elizabeth Galloway, Agnes Clark, and Harriet Ahearn.
1) Meets:
2/16 - Dorothy Jack and Hilda Gaylord
lost on the Aff at Washington State College debating
the resolution “Resolved, that co-education as practical in American
institutions of higher education is a failure.” Afterwards, they traveled to
the
2/20
- Agnes Clark and Harriet Ahearn lost on the Aff at
Oregon State College, debating the resolution “Resolved, that mass education at
American colleges and universities should be abandoned.”
2/28
- Elizabeth Galloway and Catherine Bleakney lost on
the Neg at Oregon State College debating the
“mass-education” topic
2) Katherine Kiesling
and Elma Proffit were incapacitated by the mumps
outbreak
D.
Men’s
debate:
1) Topic: “Resolved, that American investors and investments in foreign nations
should be protected only by the government in which the investments are made.”
2) Meets:
3/1 - Richard Van Horn and Eugene Klise, Aff vs. Weber
3/2 - Richard Van Horn and Henry Taylor,
Aff at
3/3 -
3/5 - Henry Taylor and Eugene Klise, Aff vs. Oregon
4/5 -
E.
On
December 7 a three-man team from
1)
the
2) the Whitman team: Harry Rothrock, Henry Taylor, and Mark Bradford
3) The Resolution: “Resolved that
this house disapproves of woman” (Whitman was Neg)
4) 13 minute constructives;
one 8 minute rebuttal per team
5) Professor W.R. Davis presided
F.
IM
debates were held on a class (Freshmen, Sophomores, Juniors, Seniors) basis
1) the resolution and other details
were decided on by a committee of students
a) times were 7min constructives; 4min rebuttals; debates were two-on-two
b) men’s resolution: “Resolved,
that the plea of insanity in defense of crime be abolished (constitutionality
is waived)”
c) women’s resolution:
“Resolved, that this house condemns the large part played by advertising in
modern life.”
2) no senior
teams entered, giving the junior teams a leg straight into finals
3) Men: Freshmen Kenneth Davis and Ralph
Edgerton (Neg) beat Juniors Harold Fleharty and Charles Ogden in the final round.
4) Women: Freshmen Lola Sims and Ruth
Blaine beat Juniors Eleanor Dunlap and Leila Lundy
G. The Pacific Coast
Forensics League Tournament (which consisted of only oration and extemporaneous
speaking) amended the extemporaneous speaking event so that schools would
receive absolutely no clues as to the topic before arriving at the tournament.
1) Harry Rothrock
was selected to represent Whitman at this tournament (he couldn’t do extemp, since he had taken first the year before). Clark Eckart was the alternate. (There was no opportunity for
women to compete at this tournament). Rothrock’s
oratory was on “Valleys of Forgotten Men.”
2) Tournament was held at Pomona College
3) There was a $50 prize for 1st
place and a $25 prize for 2nd.
4) Results
Oratory:
1st – Arizona University
2nd – University of
California
3rd – USC
Extemp
1st – Stanford
2nd – Pomona
A measure to form a women’s league was
voted down
President Cable of Arizona University
was elected League President
Professor Veatch of Washington State College
was elected League Vice President
H.
The
Dovell speech contest was barred from Freshmen; speeches had to be 2000 words or less; the topic
had to be approved by the English department.
1) There were 14 entries. They held a
preliminary round to choose 4 finalists.
2) Finalists:
Irma Kinnison;
Stephen Penrose, Jr.; Harry Rothrock; Richard Van
Horn; Chester Babcock – Alternate
1st – Irma Kinnison (class of ’30)
2nd – Stephen Penrose, Jr. (class
of ’28)
I.
The
John Brining extemporaneous speaking contest was held for freshmen only.
1) Women finalists:
Ruth Blaine, Cornelia Hansen, Katherine Kiesling, Catherine Ogden (Harriet Ahearn and Freda Herndon
as alternates)
Winner: Ruth Blaine
2) Men finalists:
Kenneth Davis, Albert Garretson, Gordon Manseir, Donald Rader (Howard Rosheim
and Ralph Edgerton as alternates)
Winner: Albert Garretson
J.
Two
trophies were adopted to be awarded to the campus organization with the most
members participating in forensic activities (Varsity debate, Speaking
contests, Intramural debates, and Pacific Coast Forensics League Contests)